September 24, 2003
Age of Parity? Or is it Mediocrity?

For the third week in a row, the league standings remained virtually unchanged as almost every team in contention for the second stage title earned a single point, and marched in step to the following week. As long-time readers will know, The Rising Sun News was strongly opposed to the idea of eliminating sudden-death extra time from the J.League format. Though the arguments in favour of this change were numerous, and had some persuasive elements, the conditions in the league over the past three weeks highlight exactly the sort of dreary mediocrity that we feared would emerge once extra time was eliminated.

Several of this week's matches were sullied by the transparent effort, on the part of many contestants, to "play for the draw". In their match against Kashima Antlers, for example, Kyoto Purple Sanga was playing with six defenders for the final few minutes of the match. Meanwhile, Oita Trinita is plumbing new depths in dullness, boasting the fewest goals conceded of any team in the league, yet on course to shatter the record for the fewest goals scored in a season. This may be very much a part of the European footballing tradition. However, one of the things that made the J.League so "different" in the past -- and for that matter, more exciting -- was the fact that teams almost always "played to win", right down to the final whistle. Nowadays, it seems, most teams play "not to lose". And the flair and excitement tht once was a hallmark of the J.League has clearly suffered as a result. Here are the sad statistics from Week 7:
Date Home.VisitorVenue
23 Sep2-2Komaba Stadium
23 Sep1-1Kobe Wing Stadium
23 Sep1-2Ajinomoto Stadium
23 Sep0-0Nihondaira Stadium
23 Sep3-1Mizuho Stadium
23 Sep1-1Kashima Stadium
23 Sep1-0Kashiwa-no-ha Stadium
23 Sep2-2Expo'70 Stadium


2 - 2

The match between JEF United and Urawa Reds is perhaps the best illustration of our disgust with the new league format. This budding rivalry produced 60 minutes of fascinating action. If both teams faced the prospect of extra time to determine a winner, one way or the other, it might have gone down as one of the classics in league history. But just like the Kashima Antlers-Jubilo Iwata match last weekend, this clash fizzled out into an overcautious, defense-oriented slog through the final fifteen minutes, which left no one satisfied.

And the sad thing is, if not for the inclination of both coaches to "play for the draw", it might have been so much different. JEF United entered the game wanting dearly to win revenge for the loss that knoocked them out of the First Stage title race, and despite the absence of both starting strikers -- Choi Yong-Soo and Sandro Cardoza -- they put on an inspired performance in the first quarter hour minutes that produced a 1-0 lead. The goal was a bit flukish, with a misplayed trap by Seiichiro Maki bouncing back to him off a defender. However, the youngsrer responded with a flourish, driving the ball past the keeper and providing a chance for JEF to celebrate.

Urawa took some time to get themselves together in this match, though that has been a problem throuhgout the season. The Reds still do not play well as a team, but despite that lingering problem, the overflowing talent of the individual players eventually allowed them to establish clear control of the momentum, and in time, a goal was produced by U-22 Japan teammates Keita Suzuki and Tatsuya Tanaka. Suzuki carried a ball down the right wing with some clever feints and cutbacks which drew the defence forward. When the JEF back line had committed themselves sufficiently to produce a gap at the back, Suzuki lofted a soft ball over their heads for Tanaka to chase. The speedy striker dashed through the flat-footed defence and reached the ball a step ahead of the keeper, looping a soft arc over the outrushing keeper and into the back of the net.

But JEF responded with the same energy and attacking fury that they showed in the first half, almost immediately restoring their lead. A steal on the left side by Masataka Sakamoto produced the chance, and although it looked like Takenori Hayashi may have been a bit offside on Sakamoto's long breakaway pass, the linesman's flag stayed down and Hayashi tuched the ball underneath the keeper.

The Reds resumed the pressure once more, and after a series of half-chances, defender Ned Zelic knotted the score once again on a fine individual effort, overlapping through the defence, firing once, and -- when that effort was blocked -- collecting the rebound and sending a second blast into the low left corner.

But no sooner had the second goal hit the nylon than both teams suddenly seemed to turn off the spotlights, lower the curtain and prepare for their post-match showers. As all 22 players marked time waiting for the final whisltle, we could only think what a sad end it was to an otherwise stirring match


1 - 1

In Kashima, meanwhile, fans had to contend not only with dreadfully dreary defensive tactics by Kyoto, but also some simply unbelievable officiating calls. Kyoto got an early goal when Teruaki Kurobe plowed right over keeper Hitoshi Sogahata on a high ball into the box, bowling him over completely and knocking the ball loose. The referee ignored the obvious foul, as Regillio "Reggie" Simons pushed the ball into the empty net. Nor would that be the end to the questionable calls. Late in the second half, Mitsuo Ogasawara was upended dramatically in the Kyoto penalty box, and though the defender never came close to touching the ball, the referee sinply waved play on.

Kashima did manage to equalise, as a fine cross from Masashi Motoyama was headed home by Tomoyuki Hirase, but thereafter Kyoto brought in three additional defenders and played 11-men-in-the-box until the final whistle. At the end of the match, the Antlers fans booed long and loud, though it was unclear whether they were decrying the poor finishing of their own strikers, the dreadfully dull play by Sanga, or the inept performance of the officiating team. All three, it must be said, deserved every bit of jeering the fans could muster.


1 - 1

That's right. The Yokohama Marinos -- first stage champions, and now nearly back to full strength -- also sleepwalked to a draw, against a team that seems headed for almost certain relegation. And to make matters worse, they were unable to capture three points from this match even though Kobe played for the final 15 minutes with just ten men


2 - 2

And if you think THAT's sad, how about Gamba Osaka, who squandered a two goal lead in the final quarter hour, and for the second time in three days allowed their opponent to equalise in injury time!


0 - 0

But worst of all was the futile contest between Oita Trinita and Shimizu S-Pulse. Was it really that bad? Im afraid I cant say for sure. Ive tried to watch the tape twice -- both last night and again this morning -- but fell asleep before the first fifteen minutes had elapsed. At least I know I have a sure-fire solution if I should ever suffer from insomnia.


Elsewhere

Jubilo Iwata got back into the winning form with a 2-1 victory over FC Tokyo. The biggest news in this match was an injury to midfielder Naohiro Ishikawa, who has been the team's biggest offensive weapon and a standout star on the U-22 team as well. No report yet on how long he may be sidelined.

Nagoya Grampus joined the Antlers at the top of the table following a victory over Cerezo Osaka. Now that they have joined the group at the head of the pack, we can probably expect them to start playing for draws, beginning next week.

Last and least, Vegalta Sendai continued their march towards relegation, losing a 1-0 decision to lowly Kashiwa Reysol.


Following the splurge of drawn matches this week, the league table looks almost identical to last week, with the sole exception of. Nagoya Grampus' move to the top of the table, level on points with Kashima.

.TeamPtsGPWDLGFGAGDif
1Nagoya Grampus 1374121410+4
2Kashima Antlers 13734085+3
3Tokyo Verdy 1273311711+6
4Yokohama Marinos 127331149+5
5JEF United Ichihara 1273311310+3
6Kashiwa Reysol 12733164+2
7Urawa Reds 117322119+2
8Gamba Osaka 107241109+1
9F.C.Tokyo 972321311+2
10Jubilo Iwata 97232910-1
11Shimizu S-Pulse 97232911-2
12Kyoto Purple Sanga 87223811-3
13Oita Trinita 4704326-4
14Cerezo Osaka 471151217-5
15Vegalta Sendai 47043713-6
16Vissel Kobe 37034512-7


Back Numbers


Send all questions, comments and queries to:






Site
 Meter